Words Matter

Friday’s broadcast of Radio Lab is of note.


This episode of Radio Lab is important because it indirectly sheds light on the animal mind.

A linguist travelled to a South American village that housed a school for deaf children because the children had invented a new language in their unique manner of signing. The linguist wanted to document the evolution of a language in real time through successive generations of students entering the school and picking it up as it’s not often that one can talk to both the inventors of a language as well as to its latest iterators. Not surprisingly she found that as the language matured over the years, new acquisitors added new words and were able to communicate far more information with increasingly subtle gestures. The earliest acquirers used large body movements to express themselves whereas the later acquirers could express even more with a mere inflection of their wrist. What was surprising however was that when the early acquirers were asked to describe a story they had been shown in a video, they retold it as a sequence of events, this happened and then that happened. Whereas the later acquirers would retell the same story but in terms of the mental states of the characters in the story. This character was feeling this when that happened and so this internal state led to that external event. Being intrigued with this finding, the linguist next tested the acquirers with a theory of mind experiment. They were presented with a story of two brothers playing with the older brother’s toy train in the older brother’s bedroom. The older brother before leaving to get something to eat from the kitchen, placed the toy under his bed and admonished his younger brother to leave it there. Of course as soon as he left the room his younger brother took the train out and secreted it in a toy chest. Eventually the older brother returned to his room to resume playing and so the students were asked where the older brother was likely to look for the toy train.

The children who had acquired the most developed version of the language answered that the older brother would look under the bed because in his mind, that was where he believed the train was when he left the room. However the older students who had acquired the crudest version of the language in the first wave of acquisition and were now thirty years old, answered that the older brother would look in the toy chest. They had no idea of relative points of view given the passage of time.

As it turned out, in the original version of the sign language there was only one term for a state of knowing and it existed in the present moment. Whereas in the more refined version of the language, there were now twelve terms for various states of knowing and these embellished a far more refined comprehension of how points of view change relative to the passage of time.

Words matter. If human beings with a highly evolved intellect do not automatically manifest a particularly robust theory of mind by virtue of lacking a terminology that embodies a theory of mind (relative points of view predicated on Time—these are both the same thing) how could animals be expected to manifest a theory of mind when they live wholly in the present tense and as far as we know have no terms for objects (not to mention points of view) evolving over time? An animal takes each moment as it is. Because words matter this study should immediately call into question the experiments on animal cognition which researchers have interpreted as indicating a theory of mind, for example, the experiment in the recent issue of National Geographic purporting to demonstrate that dogs have an innate sense of fairness. Whereas I propose that the phenomenon of physical memory (a whole body cellular record of emotional experience that evokes and carries forward the physical and universal feeling of motion) will prove a far more comprehensive and parsimonious interpretation of such experiments. The past lives on in the moment by way of physical memory. This networking of minds is the design of nature.

Want to Learn More about Natural Dog Training?

Join the exclusive and interactive group that will allow you to ask questions and take part in discussions with the founder of the Natural Dog Training method, Kevin Behan.

Join over 65 Natural Dog trainers and owners, discussing hundreds of dog training topics with photos and videos!

We will cover such topics as natural puppy rearing, and how to properly develop your dog's drive and use it to create an emotional bond and achieve obedience as a result.

Create Your Account Today!

Published March 31, 2012 by Kevin Behan
Tags: , , , ,

4 responses to “Words Matter”

  1. john says:

    that is mind blowing, thanks for sharing that,,

  2. Annie says:

    As a songwriter, I enjoy the challenge of distilling a sentiment or story into a moment; words have always mattered to me, and this article is fascinating; if I were a linguist, I would also be interested in documenting the breakdown of “traditional” language as texting and rapping continue to rapidly introduce new combinations of words and symbols that communicate specific situations. In the end, all of these diverse efforts seek to describe common sensory experiences in an innovative way. (Having said that, I still don’t like it when jacuzzi is forced to rhyme with Gucci, or lady, with baby and crazy!) It’s my opinion that many systems, as we know them, are beginning to break down….religious, political, language, socio-economic, eco-systems….it seems that the energetic effect of all of this disintegration could be part of a design to restore collective consciousness to the present.

  3. 123 says:

    Is this in any way relevant to your theory?


  4. kbehan says:

    In my view the mirror neurons are the neurological nuts and bolts of how the emotional projection phenomenon is mediated by the central nervous system and so I believe it is relevant to my theory since it shows such a straight one to one transference. The meaning for the observing dog that’s picking up the transference via its mirror neurons, however would derive from a deeper emotional dynamic (and which is then implemented by the mirror neurons) and would depend on what level of elaboration is being attained by the two individuals, if we’re talking about an interaction, and then how much emotional energy is moving and then the quality of it, as in electrostatic pressure, or magnetic sensuality.

Leave a Reply

Books about Natural Dog Training by Kevin Behan

In Your Dog Is Your Mirror, dog trainer Kevin Behan proposes a radical new model for understanding canine behavior: a dog’s behavior and emotion, indeed its very cognition, are driven by our emotion. The dog doesn’t respond to what the owner thinks, says, or does; it responds to what the owner feels. And in this way, dogs can actually put people back in touch with their own emotions. Behan demonstrates that dogs and humans are connected more profoundly than has ever been imagined — by heart — and that this approach to dog cognition can help us understand many of dogs’ most inscrutable behaviors. This groundbreaking, provocative book opens the door to a whole new understanding between species, and perhaps a whole new understanding of ourselves.
  Natural Dog Training is about how dogs see the world and what this means in regards to training. The first part of this book presents a new theory for the social behavior of canines, featuring the drive to hunt, not the pack instincts, as seminal to canine behavior. The second part reinterprets how dogs actually learn. The third section presents exercises and handling techniques to put this theory into practice with a puppy. The final section sets forth a training program with a special emphasis on coming when called.
%d bloggers like this: